The+Case+of+David

Back to Home>Back to Evidence and Certainty

= Competing Paradigms = One of the common characteristics of the Human Sciences (although not completely absent from the Natural Sciences) is the existence of competing paradigms within one subject to explain the same observed phenomenon. Whether discussing the meaning of employment data from a Keynesian or Neo-Classical perspective, or Malthus vs. Boserup's understanding of the relationship between food production and population growth, the Human Sciences, inherent in their methodology, can approach problems from multiple perspectives. Does this characteristic help or hinder the creation, and validity, of knowledge claims within this area of knowledge?

In order to answer this question more thoroughly, we are going to become psychologists for a short while. You will be each divided into 5 groups around some of the different paradigms of diagnosis, analysis and treatment that exist in psychology. Each group will be expected to first familarize themselves with their perspective and do some background research to attempt to become "masters" of the approach in 5 minutes. You will then attempt to create a one page analysis of the below scenario that: 1. Explains the Perspective

2. Recommends avenues for future investigation

3. Articulates actions to address the problems presented by the scenario (15 mins).

Each group will present their assessment and recommendations (90 seconds per group) and we will discuss the merits of each diagnosis. //Davids History//

1. The Biological Perspective- The biological perspective is the scientific explanation for the actions and behaviors of living things. It can include genetics, hormonal or bio-chemical causes such as chemical imbalances. The brain is of prime importance in explaining behavior. The working of the nervous systems is one of the crucial functions in explaining human behavior. More Details- &

2. The Behaviourist Perspective- The behavioral perspective is based on the idea that performance is focused on the need to obtain rewards, and avoid punishment or disagreeable occurrences. More details-